Adapted from Stellenbosch University release – updated 27/03/2020

Stellenbosch – The uncontrolled harvesting of timber, bark and poles from indigenous forests in the Eastern Cape is having a negative impact on bird diversity, a new FBIP-funded study has shown.

The Eastern Cape is home to 46% of South Africa’s remaining natural forests.

The region includes many of the country’s most threatened forest types, and forms part of the Maputuland-Pondoland-Albany Hotspot for biodiversity.

However, while there has been an increase in forest cover in these areas, uncontrolled bark harvesting is leading to the degradation of forests.

‘Sensitive to disturbance’

Stellenbosch University PhD student student Jessica Leaver and her fellow researchers investigated the impact of timber, pole and bark harvesting on bird diversity in five Eastern Cape forests: Mqaba, Manubi, Ntlaboya, Gomo and Pirie.

The study was published in the journal Forest Ecology and Management.

eastern cape forests

Location of the five study forests in the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa.

But instead of looking only at the number of species, they focused on the number of ecological roles filled by birds within the forest.

“Species that perform more diverse and specialised roles in a forest are more likely to be more sensitive to disturbance,” Leaver explained.

The Foundational Biodiversity Information Programme (FBIP) is funded through the Department of Science and Innovation (DSI)‘s Global Change Research Plan and is jointly managed by the South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI) and the National Research Foundation (NRF).

‘Ring barking’

Co-author and FBIP Eastern Cape forests project Principal Investigator Prof Michael Cherry, said the persistence of bird diversity is critical for the functioning and regeneration of these forest systems, some of them at least five million years old.

Cherry said many different species of birds play very important roles in these forests, such as with the dispersal of seeds and pollination.

“When these birds and the functions they perform start to disappear, the overall health and resilience of the forest is affected,” he warned.

Overall 64 bird species were recorded across the five forests: 23 species at Gomo; 42 species at Mqaba; 51 species at Manubi; 44 at Ntlaboya; and 38 at Pirie.

This is the first time that a baseline study of this nature on these forests has been published.

Leaver’s work shows that 29% of trees from which bark has been removed in these forests have been ring-barked, which means the bark has been removed from around the entire circumference of a tree, leading to its slow but inevitable death.

bark harvesting eastern cape forests

Researchers estimate that just under 30% of trees in five indigenous forests of the Eastern Cape have been ring-barked – which leads to eventual death. Pictured here is a ring-barked black stinkwood (Ocotea bullata) in Gomo forest. Photo: Jessica Leaver

Insect-eating birds like the Southern Black Flycatcher (Melaenornis pammelaina), the Blue-mantled Crested Flycatcher (Trochocercus cyanomelas), and the African Dusky Flycatcher (Muscicapa adusta) may be negatively affected because, as more sunlight penetrates the canopy due to more trees dying, there may be fewer insects on the forest floor.

Three species of seed-eaters, the Forest Canary (Crithagra scotops), the Green Twinspot (Mandingoa nitidula) and the Lemon Dove (Aplopelia larvata), are also negatively affected by bark harvesting.

Again, more sunlight penetrating the canopy cover leads to more foliage plants and less grass on the forest floor, thereby reducing the availability of seeds.

Range declines

Pole harvesting, i.e. the selective removal of sub-canopy trees , also negatively affected forest specialist species such as the Dark-backed Weaver (Ploceus bicolor), the Grey Cuckooshrike (Coracina caesia), the Olive Bushshrike (Chlorophoneus olivaceus), the Yellow-streaked Greenbul (Phyllastrephus flavostriatus) and the Yellow-throated Woodland Warbler (Phylloscopus ruficapilla) – forest birds which are mostly found in the tree canopy.

Conversely, generalist species such as the Cape White-eye (Zosterops capensis) and the Black-headed Oriole (Oriolus larvatus) were found to be positively affected by pole harvesting.

Generalist species are more easily able to take advantage of habitat changes.

A 2017 study Cherry’s group showed that half of South Africa’s forest dependent bird species had experienced range declines since 1992.

Declines were most prominent in the Eastern Cape, despite an increase in forest cover in this region over the same period.

“It now seems likely that habitat degradation arising from informal harvesting is negatively affecting the number of ecological roles filled by forest birds in this region, thus contributing to their decline,” Cherry warned.

The article “Response of bird functional diversity to forest product harvesting in the Eastern Cape, South Africa” was published in the journal Forest Ecology and Management recently.

READ MORE: Four cryptic species uncovered within forest gecko

Response of bird functional diversity to forest harvesting in Eastern Cape, SA by Dane McDonald on Scribd